"GenAI does not create, it appropriates:" European video game unions publish manifesto demanding generative AI regulation
"We do not have to accept the use of genAI to make video games; it is not inevitable."
"We do not have to accept the use of genAI to make video games; it is not inevitable."
A collective of video game unions and work councils from across Europe have published a manifesto condemning the impact of generative AI (genAI) on the game industry and calling on lawmakers to regulate the technology.
The document was published on the website of UK union IWGB and written in collaboration with Game Workers Unite Ireland, Spanish union CSVI, and the FIOM-CGIL Milan Work Council.
Those behind the manifesto claim generative AI is harming the game industry, its workers, and the video games they produce. Without intervention and sufficient regulation, the believe the technology—which it defines as the LLMs and other "energy-intensive models" that can be used to generate text, pictures, videos, or music by inputting prompts—will cause irreparable harm.
Specifically, the collective argues that generative AI tech is being foisted on workers whether they like it or not, referring to reports of implicit and explicit usage mandates at some studios.
Citing multiple studies, they claim widespread usage will result in "worker fatigue, cognitive decline, and burnout" and fewer junior positions across the industry.
"GenAI has a profound negative impact on workers by reducing the availability and appeal of work. Games are best made by people, and people do their best when they are healthy and connected to their work, refining their skills and accumulating real experience," reads the manifesto.
Notably, the group firmly believe that generative AI is being touted as an alternative to human labour, and claim adopting the technology can lead to a lack of accountability and unwieldy workloads.
"Employers see genAI as a way of cutting labour costs, employing fewer workers than they would need to without it. GenAI companies ingratiate themselves with employers, by promising the impossible. Moreover, mistakes made by genAI are often blamed on the workers, rather than the employers mandating its use," the manifesto continues.
In addition, the collective stresses that generate AI has appropriated the labour of workers around the world. This is something that has been admitted by those responsible for building LLMs, such as ChatGPT maker OpenAI. In 2024, the company stated it would have been "impossible" to build its chatbot without scraping copyrighted material (via The Guardian).
The manifesto argues that generative perpetuates discrimination because the datasets used to build the tech "carry an intrinsic and exclusionary Western bias that limits diversity and marginalises non-dominant languages, cultures, and ethnicities."
Finally, the group highlights the "hidden costs" of generative AI, which they claim disincentives education by gatekeeping transferable skills and allowing those companies behind the tech to "monopolise knowledge" and sell it back to users.
"This is bad for workers, but it is also bad for employers who outsource their knowledge and skills to third-party genAI providers, as once these companies have a monopoly on this previously institutional knowledge, their prices are unlikely to remain competitive," the manifesto states.
"GenAI providers aim to replace employers’ dependence on workers with dependence on their own models. Companies which buy into this promise while genAI usage is cheap may come to regret this when it is the only option and prices increase. Workers will regret this much sooner."
In an attempt to provide actionable advice, the collective has outlined what workers, employers, players, and regulators can do to combat what they view as a technology that will only succeed in stripping the humanity from art in all of its forms.
Those recommendations are varied, but largely instruct people to take a stand by avoiding using the technology where possible, talking to their peers about associated risks and harms, and—especially in the case of players—being vocal in calling out its usage.
The group has also backed the UTAW Tech Workers' Inquiry in calling for legal protections for employees who refuse to use generative AI and safeguards that protect people and the planet from broader harms related to the tech.
Here's an excerpt detailing some of those policy proposals:
We need a regulatory framework with teeth to hold employers and technology companies accountable for their use of AI, along the following lines:
The manifesto has some additional suggestions for regulators, including one that would make it impossible for a person's work to be entered into a generative AI dataset without their explicit permission and consent—and, crucially, without compensating them fairly for their labour.
In closing, it states that generative AI "is not inevitable" and must not be viewed as such.
"Years after the public release of genAI chatbots, their use has not been as widespread as their owners would like, but they have been deployed as an excuse for mass layoffs with the goal of pleasing shareholders," concludes the manifesto.
"We should stop thinking about what is good for business, but instead think about what is good for society in general, for workers, for gamers. What good is it if a CEO earns millions every month if the working conditions at their studio are worsening, along with the video games they create? No genAI will be able to replace the humanity in any work of art."
Vertical Slice is hellbent on serving you. Show your support with a free membership or paid subscription.