Opinion: There is no product, only people
It appears the moments that make GTA VI shine are unmistakably human. Perhaps there's something in that?
The Grand Theft Auto maker has been accused of "blatant" union busting, but maintains it fired workers for leaking confidential information.
The legal battle between Rockstar and 31 fired workers based in the UK, who claim they were dismissed for engaging in trade union activity, is coming to a head this week.
Both parties are submitting their closing submissions before Judge Lucy Wiseman at Glasgow Tribunal Center, with the hearing set to conclude on November 18, 2026. That's over a year after Rockstar fired the group in October 2025.
The core argument has remained unchanged throughout. The ousted employees, who organised under the Independent Workers' Union of Great Britain, claim they were victims of "blatant" union busting.
By contrast, the Grand Theft Auto maker said it fired those workers for leaking confidential information and disparaging the company in a union Discord server, leading to a "breakdown in trust and confidence."
As we prepare to enter the home stretch, Vertical Slice has obtained copies of the closing submissions and responsive submissions submitted by the union workers (claimants) and Rockstar (respondents), which extensively detail the core arguments put forward by both sides in what could be a precedent-setting case.
Crucially, the legal filings also shed some light on how working conditions are perceived by some Rockstar employees in the UK.
One key argument tabled by the fired union workers is that Rockstar knew of the Discord server from at least early 2023, when a mole (or information provider, in the words of Rockstar) gained entry with the purpose of feeding information back to studio leaders, such as Rockstar HR manager Charlie Kinlock.
The claimants question why Rockstar chose to allow the server to remain active if it posed an severe security risk—and note the studio only chose to dismiss union workers for purportedly leaking information when the union had reached the 10 percent threshold for statutory recognition in the UK.
"It is very difficult to see how posts on the Server can have been the reason for mass dismissals in October 2025, if the decision makers had knowledge of the Server and the nature of its contents for nearly three years before then, and took no disciplinary action at all – at least without reasonable explanation as to what changed in October 2025. It is even more difficult to see how the posts could have been the reason for urgent, summary dismissal in that context," reads the claimant's closing submission.
The union workers point out that Rockstar suggested it was a "mere coincidence" the dismissals took place at the same time union membership crossed that 10 percent threshold.
"For R’s case to be true, it would have to be one of a number of striking coincidences–including that every single one of the employees dismissed in the UK was a union member. Claimants invite the Tribunal to reject that version of events," the document adds.
Rockstar insists its focus was on "confidentiality and disparagement," and not preventing that 10 percent threshold being met.
"If, as the Claimants claim, the Respondent was hostile towards the IWGB and had been since 2023, and was fearful of it achieving the 10% recognition threshold, it would have made no sense for the Respondent to take no action until the IWGB had already reached that threshold, and then in an obvious 48 hour period dismiss 31 employees, some of who were in Canada," reads an excerpt from Rockstar's closing submission.
Rockstar restated it became "obsessive about confidentiality and information security" following multiple high-profile leaks, and claimed those union workers who were fired should not have been surprised at the company's reaction to learning they had been "sharing confidential information and engaging in widespread disparagement on an unsecure Discord server to which 350 people had access."
As for why it waited to react? Rockstar claimed it had only seen "fragments" of the Discord before October 2025, but upon seeing the server laid bare chose to react quickly. The union workers disagree.
Another point we haven't seen discussed publicly is Rockstar's handling of its appeals process. The union workers claim that Rockstar's head of education and industry relations, Gary Conti (GC), who oversaw the appeals of fired union workers, failed to implement a fair and substantive process.
They allege Conti conducted appeals in writing (via email or post) instead of meeting with workers in a more personal capacity, such as a Zoom call. He's also accused of failing to produce and maintain documentation throughout that process.
Vertical Slice is hellbent on serving you. Show your support with a free membership or paid subscription.